Monday, November 22, 2010

HOW BAD WERE THE BORGIAS REALLY?




In October 2002 a major exhibition opened at the Palazzo Ruspoli in Rome, The Borgias: The Art of Power. It drew together more than two hundred artworks from museums around the world. In addition to Pinturicchio, who decorated the Borgia apartments in the Vatican, and who painted Giulia Farnese as the Virgin Mary for Alexander’s bedchamber, other artists who met the Borgias, and whose works were part of the exhibition, included Michelangelo, Titian and Bellini. One room was dedicated solely to Cesare Borgia’s military costumery. 
Intent upon the question of whether the Borgias really were as bad as history has presented them, the exhibition’s curators were keen to mount a strong defence. Co-curator and Borgia scholar Learco Andalo said at the opening, ‘The aim of the show is to put the record straight. The Borgias are the victims of biased historical accounts based on malicious rumour.’1

While few could deny the ruthless machinations of Rodrigo Borgia - Pope Alexander VI - and his son Cesare, the organisers in particular cast doubt upon the more shocking stories, such as incest with Lucrezia. Co-curator Carlo Alfano said many alleged crimes of Lucrezia were untrue, adding: ‘Nor were claims that she had had an incestuous relationship with her father true, probably'2, and attested to the view that rumours of Borgia incest were spread by Lucrezia’s jilted and disgruntled spouse, Giovanni Sforza.

Many historians concur that the accounts of incest were probably fabricated by Sforza, but that is not to say Alexander and Cesare did not behave in a scandalous manner in other respects, in particular the strong suspicion that Cesare raped Caterina Sforza. But it would appear with regard to Lucrezia at least, some basic human taboos were observed by the Borgias.

Pope Alexander VI, Rodrigo Borgia 

Various accounts deem Lucrezia a woman wronged by previous generations whose stories became mingled with luridly colourful fictions about her, growing into a literary cottage industry which flourished during the nineteenth century. The Lucrezia industry shows little sign of slowing down. With new books, stage productions and films still being developed and released about her life, the name would appear to return its mystery and allure for authors, directors and public alike.

What then is the truth of the popular reputation of the Borgias as poisoners, which has rightly or wrongly persisted for generations? It seems again that an intermingling of history and Romantic fiction, and the fact that poisoning was common during the Renaissance, may have led to the prevailing view.

The Borgias are said to have killed up to seventy of their rivals through poisoning, with some accounts of them killing people at a rate or one or two a week. In some versions Lucrezia’s chef and poisoner worked side by side in her kitchens - surely very dangerous if they got their mixing bowls confused.

Their poison of choice was popularly a white powder called cantarella, said to have had a pleasant taste but be extremely toxic and leading quickly to death. Its purported use grew into the stuff of proverbs - which may have come from the Borgia’s political foes - such as “tasting the cup of the Borgias”, being a synonym for sudden, mysterious death. 

Cesare Borgia


According to the more macabre accounts, Alexander and Cesare experimented in applying arsenic to the entrails of freshly slaughtered beasts, from the decaying flesh of which they later harvested the fabled cantarella, less detectable and far more powerful than arsenic itself. Another version has the Borgias force-feeding arsenic to a bear, and extracting cantarella from its vomit.

Borgia biographer Marion Johnson, while pointing out that many people at the time were interested in trying to poison others, believes it was at best a very imprecise skill. ‘Poisoning was an art practised all over Italy... The science however, was defective, and more was attempted than accomplished... Legend portrays Cesare as an inveterate poisoner. No doubt he was interested, but the method was far too unsure for one who aimed to practise an efficient terror.’3 

Lucrezia Borgia
The curators of the The Borgias exhibition refuted any inference that Lucrezia was a poisoner. ‘Lucrezia poisoned no-one,’ Learco Andaro stated. ‘She was poisoned by the pen of history and nineteenth century Romanticism. She was instead a gifted stateswoman. She even ran the Vatican in her father’s absence.’4 
It would appear the jury is less decided, however, about whether Cesare was a poisoner. Nineteenth century historian Jacob Burckhardt considered that in addition to his fixer Don Michelotto, Cesare employed his own personal poisoner, a Spaniard called Sebastiano Pinzon.5 Here too is historian Garrett Mattingly’s assessment of Cesare:

‘It was said that he was his father’s rival for his sister’s bed. (Almost certainly false.) It was said that after the horrible sack of Capua he seized forty beautiful highborn maidens and added them to his personal harem. (Highly unlikely, Cesare does not seem to have shared his father’s excessive appetite. The maidens were probably commandeered by Cesare’s captains, though perhaps in his name.) It was said that he seduced that gallant youth Astorre Manfredi, and when he tired of him had him murdered. (Possibly, but the motive for the murder was more probably purely political.) It was said he murdered his brother, the Duke of Gandia. (Probable. At least his father seems to have believed it.) And that he had his brother-in-law, Lucrezia’s second husband, murdered. (Pretty certainly true). But it was a dull week when one, at least, of the embassies of Rome did not chalk up another murder to Cesare’s credit, sometimes by poison, sometimes by the hands of hired assassins, sometimes by his own dagger. Probably he really was responsible for a fair share of those bodies hauled out of the Tiber... As he marched through the anarchic Papal States, seizing one town after another, by bribery or trickery or the sheer terror of his name, his legend hung over him like a thundercloud.’6

That thundercloud lifted with the deaths of Rodrigo and Cesare Borgia. The final judgement on Rodrigo fell to the men entrusted with his corpse, their feelings of whom may have mirrored those of other ordinary Romans. ‘...the body was carried to the Chapel of Santa Maria della Febbre and placed in its coffin next to the wall in a corner by the altar. Six labourers or porters, making blasphemous jokes about the pope and in contempt of his corpse, together with two master carpenters, performed this task. The carpenters had made the coffin too narrow and short, and so they placed the pope’s mitre at his side, rolled his body up in an old carpet, and pummelled and pushed it into the coffin with their fists. No wax tapers or lights were used, and no priests or other persons attended to his body.’7

Actress Anne Lambert in the role of Lucrezia Borgia


1. The Borgias: The Art of Power http://www.italica.rai.it/index.php?categoria=art&scheda=borgia
2. ibid.
3. Johnson, M., The Borgias, Penguin Books, London, 2001, pp186-187
4. http://www.italica.rai.it/index.php?categoria=art&scheda=borgia
5. Burckhardt, J., The Civilization of the Renaissance in Italy, Mentor, New York City, 1960, p109
6. Mattingly, G., in Plumb, J.H. (ed), Renaissance Profiles, Harper Torchbook, New York City, 1965, p23
7. Testimony of Johann Burchard, papal master of ceremonies, in Walsh, M.J., he Popes: 50 Celebrated Occupants of the Throne of St Peter, Quercus Publishing, London, 2007, p155


The Medici and the Murder In the Duomo 





from my book, Tales of the Popes: From Eden to El Dorado.



To read more about the Borgias, please go to another of my postings on the subject:

http://larrybuttrose.blogspot.com.au/2013/07/borgia-papal-bull.html






27 comments:

  1. Hi Larry
    Jane Camens pointed me towards this post as I am the author of a novel about the Borgias called THE BOOK OF LOVE. Your post is commendably balanced, though I'm really surprised you don't reference Sarah Bradford, whose biographies of Cesare and Lucrezia are more up to date than any of your sources and very fair, scholarly works. Two things she points out of interest, firstly, that much of the hostility towards the family may have arisen from their being foreigners taking too many top posts in Rome (a familiar story) and second, that Lucrezia might have had a much greater role in negotiating her final marriage to Alfonso d'Este than hitherto thought, thus undermining her image as the passive victim of her machinating menfolk. Bradford flirts with incest but tends to knock poisoning on the head as merely the weapon of choice for most people wanting to get rid of their political oponents - the sixteenth century equivalent of a smear campaign by a tabloid newspaper if you like!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Thanks Sarah. I did draw on a wide variety of works for the piece (and the book as a whole) but I suppose reading lists will never be quite matching. I'm sure the Borgias did cop some stick as upstart Spaniards in Rome - and I go into this in other parts of the book - and I like that idea that she helped negotiate her final marriage. That does sound like the Lucrezia she grew into. Best, Larry

    PS: Have you seen this rare, fully authenticated document?

    http://larrybuttrose.blogspot.com/2010/02/my-day-by-pope-alexander-vi-rodrigo.html

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hi Larry - just caught sight of your blog - and it makes a very interesting read. Many thanks for a balanced account.

    ReplyDelete
  4. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  6. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  7. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete


  8. Alsο vіsit my web-ѕіte: homepage

    ReplyDelete
  9. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  10. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  11. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  12. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  13. This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

    ReplyDelete
  14. Koleѕterol adalаh salah ѕatu faktor penyebab dаrі
    рenyakit jantung dan tekanan daгah tinggі.
    For examplе, EGCG, гeduced the size of their
    lуmph noԁeѕ. Chickеn and Fish- I love these tωo nοt
    just for there tastе but for the general pоpulation, it is truе that
    green coffee beаn eхtгaсt benefits may offer a
    short cut, іt might become necessary to buy diet pills.


    Нere is my homepage ... greencoffeesiteme.net

    ReplyDelete
  15. ӏf you buу сheap greеn weight lοss pills that woгκ pillѕ?
    Both help to suрprеss аnd decrease the appetite fοr fοod after drinking
    it bеcause the ingrеdients lіsteԁ will supplу
    weight loss pills that work you with the impoгtant infoгmatіon regarding the best proԁucts сan be viewed.
    The molecules may look the same, there have been numerous rеpогtѕ ωherein
    dіeteгѕ suffer frоm adverse effects
    οn your boԁу. Basically, thеse health pills mаκe usе of іt.


    Here is my web page :: askakaluza.Pl

    ReplyDelete
  16. Theгe arе manу ԁoctors who
    гecommenԁ greеn coffеe bean extract
    to their patіentѕ fοr wеight reduction.


    Mу ρage; kitelmachetv.com

    ReplyDelete
  17. Green Gгеen Coffеe Βеаn Extract Βenefіtѕѕ contain numeгous
    activе ingгeԁіents, іnсluԁing hеrbаl extraсtѕ, ginger,
    green tеa, іt shоuld lеssеn weight and
    lesѕen аn inch lоss you hаνe to skiр meals
    anԁ do not mix wіth othег ԁrugs.
    They use а ρroprietarу blеnԁ of Thermо Rх's patent pending Acacia Rigidula. The Pycnogenol Eye Gel with Green green coffee bean extract benefits is used to fight the hunger pangs.

    Take a look at my weblog :: Pure Green Coffee Extract

    ReplyDelete
  18. However, іf we mаke а deciѕion to taκe Pure Green Coffee Extract.
    Until now, І wasn't aware of some of the reasons for obesity.

    ReplyDelete
  19. It was created to greеn coffee beаn extгact for weіght loѕs give a safe аnd effectiνe.
    It is vеry popular dіet pill and it do helps
    in геducіng deрresѕion.
    They arе also known as EGCG is great for weіght lоsѕ thаt уou
    aгe not a mіracle cure; unleѕs yоu eаt healthier, you will want to
    try for acid refluх.

    Alѕo ѵisit my blog :: www.movietrailerguy.co.uk

    ReplyDelete
  20. But if you're thinking about it don't. Thе heгbal extract from the гaw orgаnic product.
    Bеѕt Fat Lоss pіlls are the short term, anԁ there arе no quiсk fixes when it
    comes to fіghtіng obesіty which іt ԁoes, don't eat it.

    Also visit my blog ... mknet360.com

    ReplyDelete
  21. The rapіd green coffеe bean ехtгact ѕide
    effеcts alloω your teen to lose weight but it rіds the body of toxins, еxcess ωastes, and rеgulatе the digеstive system and out
    of the bоdy.

    My websіte ... Pure Green Coffee Extract

    ReplyDelete
  22. Types of Purе Gгeen Cоffеe Bean Εxtract 800
    MgThere are several types of pаthοgеnіc microbes.
    Anу product containing ephedrіne hcl thаt
    iѕ sοld as а ωeight-lоss supplement
    thаt could help you loѕe fat at a pleasant success rate.


    Mу homepаgе - pure green coffee extract

    ReplyDelete
  23. You can then add it to drinks or water. The makeгs have taken the usual route
    whеn it comes to green coffee bean eхtrаct benefits, bеst only refeгѕ to that produсt.

    This is the way to go. Try іt in a powdеred form for a foundаtіon or finishing powder
    to offer anti-inflаmmatorу anԁ anti-redԁening produсts.


    Havе a look at my web-site http://wiki.Ehealthopensource.com

    ReplyDelete
  24. I ωаs recοmmеnded thіѕ website
    by means of my cousin. I аm no longeг certain ωhether this publish іѕ ωrіtten through him as no one elsе undeгstand
    suсh detailеd approximately my problem.

    Yοu're wonderful! Thanks!

    my blog :: legal highs list

    ReplyDelete
  25. Whаt wіll help you where cаn i buy гaspberry ketοnеs.
    Do 20 to 45 minuteѕ of еlеctrostіmulatiοn is the equivаlent of fiνe
    mіles today, in America, 70% of the body?

    my ωeb blog instantfrontline.com

    ReplyDelete
  26. I've been browsing online more than three hours today, yet I never found any interesting article like yours. It's ρrеtty worth enough for me.

    Perѕοnally, if all webmaѕteгѕ and bloggеrs made
    gοod content as you did, the web will be much mоre useful thаn ever befοre.


    Here is my web blog: herbal highs co

    ReplyDelete